CIRCLEOFROSES Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> In his 3 wins he beat
> Setsuko
> Clubhouse Ride
> Will Take Charge
> Is that enough?to get in?


I am not going to dismiss Clubhouse Ride and Will Take Charge so easily; they
have both earned in excess of $1,000,000.

I will concede that Dude is probably a cut below the great geldings Kelso,
Forego and John Henry. Of more pressing concern to me is whether the gelding
Big Business (probably not HOF material but certainly in very good form) is a
single in Saturday's 4th at Belmont.

Maybe the Varick Street boys will post the Dude's graph, which should also be
in the Archives; then we can determine whether he belongs in the TG HOF, which
includes Ghostzapper and Commentator, but not Zenyatta.