Your Ask The Experts ID
is separate from your
Order Online Account ID
 Race of the Week:  The Modesty Stakes Churchill May 3, 2024  • 2 Specials Available
Order Online
Buy TG Data
Complete Menu of
TG Data products
Simulcast Books
Customize a Value
Package of Select
TG Data
Sheet Requests
Order The Last Figure for Any Horse
Free Products
Redboard Room
Download and Review previous days' data.
Race of the Week
With detailed comments
ThoroTrack
Email notification when your horse races
Information
Introduction
For newcomers.
Samples and Tutorials
For Horsemen
Consulting services and Graph Racing
Sales Sites
Where to buy TG around the country
Archives
Historical races and handicapping articles
Handicapping
Hall of Fame
Major handicapping contest winners
Home Page
Some thoughts in support of Grade One Handicap Races (1170 Views)
Posted by: Thehoarsehorseplayer (IP Logged)
Date: February 09, 2004 01:56PM

Every few years the argument that Grade One Handicaps should be eliminated from the Racing Menu raises its tired head and then a series of races comes along that puts that puppy (which seems to me born and bred of dog track sensibilities) back to sleep.
The last time I remember the anti-Grade One arguments gaining traction was in 2001. And then Point Given's Haskell/Travers races came along to pretty much silence that argument for a while. If you remember the races, the Haskell was a classic, the Travers a yawner.
In the Haskell, Point Given carrying 124 had to dig deep inside himself to run down the lightweighted longshot Touch Tone (115) in the stretch. The long shot players were yelling hopes and Point Given's backers were yelling prayers and everybody who was present at Monmouth on that glorious and pandemonious day knew they had seen something special. Two weeks later Point Given walked over his peers at equal weight in the Travers. And the hushed crowd began walking to Siro's.
But I guess where one comes down on this argument depends upon what one wants from Racing. If you want to see horses prove their courage, and test themselves against the great horses of the past by conceding weight to their contemporaries, you want to see Grade One Handicaps remain on the Racing Menu. If you're looking for something to single in a pick three with All-All (ah,what sportsmen these trawlers be) I guess even weights in all Grade Ones makes sense.
But remember this: If the Prince had not offered to have his charge carry a few extra stone in order to persuade the reluctant Earl to bet upon his once defeated steed again, there would not have been a rematch. There would not have been a Sport of Kings.
Racing has always been about conceding weight. And, it seems to me, if one doesn't understand this, one doesn't really understand the nature of Racing. One really doesn't understand the history, the traditions, the challenges, the greatness, the raison d'être of Racing. One doesn't really understand the Sport.
Indeed, Racing without Grade One Handicaps seems to me kind of like a Heavy Weight Championship Bout where punches to the head were not allowed. I'm not saying it wouldn't be enjoyable, but it certainly wouldn't be the same thing.



Post Edited (02-09-04 17:05)



Subject Written By Posted
Some thoughts in support of Grade One Handicap Races (1170 Views) Thehoarsehorseplayer 02/09/2004 01:56PM
Re: Some thoughts in support of Grade One Handicap Races (603 Views) Michael D. 02/09/2004 06:32PM
Re: Some thoughts in support of Grade One Handicap Races (591 Views) Silver Charm 02/09/2004 07:17PM
Re: Some thoughts in support of Grade One Handicap Races (620 Views) Thehoarsehorseplayer 02/09/2004 07:26PM
Re: Some thoughts in support of Grade One Handicap Races (541 Views) Michael D. 02/09/2004 08:21PM
Re: Some thoughts in support of Grade One Handicap Races (692 Views) P-Dub 02/10/2004 12:38AM
Re: Thoughts in support of Grade I Hdcp Races (511 Views) Silver Charm 02/10/2004 09:10AM
Re: Thoughts in support of Grade I Hdcp Races (712 Views) ronwar 02/10/2004 11:29AM
Re: Thoughts in support of Grade I Hdcp Races (569 Views) Michael D. 02/10/2004 01:33PM
Re: Thoughts in support of Grade I Hdcp Races (636 Views) TGJB 02/10/2004 01:56PM
Re: Thoughts in support of Grade I Hdcp Races (552 Views) Silver Charm 02/10/2004 02:11PM
Re: Some thoughts in support of Grade One Handicap Races (646 Views) Thehoarsehorseplayer 02/10/2004 03:29PM
Re: Some thoughts in support of Grade One Handicap Races (582 Views) Michael D. 02/10/2004 04:05PM
Re: Some thoughts in support of Grade One Handicap Races (711 Views) gowand 02/10/2004 05:04PM
Re: Some thoughts in support of Grade One Handicap Races (582 Views) derby1592 02/10/2004 07:05PM
Re: Some thoughts in support of Grade One Handicap Races (537 Views) Chuckles_the_Clown2 02/11/2004 02:39AM
Re: Some thoughts in support of Grade One Handicap Races (657 Views) Silver Charm 02/11/2004 10:59AM
Re: Some thoughts in support of Grade One Handicap Races (552 Views) Michael D. 02/11/2004 02:13PM
Re: Some thoughts in support of Grade One Handicap Races (631 Views) 02/11/2004 03:52PM
Re: Some thoughts in support of Grade One Handicap Races (596 Views) derby1592 02/12/2004 01:54PM
Re: Some thoughts in support of Grade One Handicap Races (591 Views) Phalaris 02/18/2004 02:44PM


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
This forum powered by Phorum.

Thoro-Graph 180 Varick Street New York, NY 10014 ---- Click here for the Ask The Experts Archives.