Your Ask The Experts ID
is separate from your
Order Online Account ID
 Race of the Week:  2024 Kentucky Oaks/Derby Days Final Figures Churchill Downs May 3 & May 4, 2024 
Order Online
Buy TG Data
Complete Menu of
TG Data products
Simulcast Books
Customize a Value
Package of Select
TG Data
Sheet Requests
Order The Last Figure for Any Horse
Free Products
Redboard Room
Download and Review previous days' data.
Race of the Week
With detailed comments
ThoroTrack
Email notification when your horse races
Information
Introduction
For newcomers.
Samples and Tutorials
For Horsemen
Consulting services and Graph Racing
Sales Sites
Where to buy TG around the country
Archives
Historical races and handicapping articles
Handicapping
Hall of Fame
Major handicapping contest winners
Home Page
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (547 Views)
Posted by: (IP Logged)
Date: July 12, 2005 02:14PM

jimbo,

I think analyzing paces and race results after the fact is useful. I'd rather have a clear understanding of all the horses' performances when they return than not.

Here's a little redboarding, but since I didn't bet the race and certainly wouldn't have bet the winner, I don't think there's any harm in presenting my thoughts prior to race.

It was obvious there was a ton of quality speed in the race. I was defintely looking for a horse that could sit just off the lead and pick up the pieces. I DON'T THINK pace figures are all that useful in determining who will get the lead. They are most useful in determining how well horses actually have been running. I think style and quality are way more important in determining how the race will actually develop, who will get the lead etc... Pace figures are secondary because horses only tend to run as fast as required early. That's one key point.

I didn't think Tosconi or Don Six fell into the category of being able to deliver a peak performance without the lead and I thought they would compromise each other's chances. Woke up Dreamin was similar, but he did have one good performance from slightly off the pace and a bunch of other speed performances in routes. There wasn't much to learn about his versatility from those routes. I was less sure he would be compromised than the others, but there was still a good chance he would. The price made the decision easy. I could never bet him at that price with the pace risks involved and the incremental possibility he might not even duplicate his last performance.

Abbodanza was similar to Woke Up Dreamin in style, but IMO wasn't nearly as good. It's always tough for me to like the 2nd and 3rd string speed horses in a race loaded with quality speed.

After that, you are really starting to fish for a play based on the assumption that you will be 100% right about your fast pace assumptions (which is a silly assumption to begin with) and that it will impact all the superior horses by enough to get an inferior horse into the winners circle. That's a common mistake. Sometimes it does hurt them, but not by enough to get a dud into the winners circle.

IMHO, the idea pre-race is to understand the possible, probable, or likely pace outcomes and use that information to adjust your odds line to reflect those insights.

If there's no one in the race that seems to be an overlay given the pace risks and running styles, skipping the race is better than betting an underlay just because you don't want to pay attention to pace, don't believe in it, or are sometimes wrong about the race development. Not betting an underlay or in a situation you aren't clear about is just as good as betting an overlay.

Another key point to me is that some people think in terms of selecting a winner or assuming you have to predict the pace with certainty. You don't. You just have to understand the probabilities of the pace and adjust your line. At a certain price I would have bet any of those speed horses even though I thought the pace was going to be very fast.

After the fact, you analyze the pace and race results and use that extra information to evaluate them better the next time they run.

In any event, this is obviously all IMHO and I'm sure there are pace applications others have to offer, but I think I bring something to the table on this issue because I've been doing it for a long time and have already made all the mistakes that most people wind up making. So I have learned from them.










Subject Written By Posted
Speed is Speed, or is it? (1152 Views) Silver Charm 07/10/2005 08:21PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (650 Views) davidrex 07/11/2005 10:31AM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (629 Views) Silver Charm 07/11/2005 01:22PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (738 Views) 07/11/2005 02:09PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (593 Views) Silver Charm 07/11/2005 09:19PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (673 Views) jbelfior 07/12/2005 09:07AM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (467 Views) Saddlecloth 07/12/2005 09:59AM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (659 Views) jimbo66 07/12/2005 11:24AM
JB-Question - Woke Up Dreaming (630 Views) jimbo66 07/12/2005 12:19PM
Re: JB-Question - Woke Up Dreaming (731 Views) TGJB 07/12/2005 02:11PM
Re: JB-Question - Woke Up Dreaming (621 Views) jimbo66 07/12/2005 03:12PM
Re: JB-Question - Woke Up Dreaming (580 Views) TGJB 07/12/2005 03:28PM
Re: JB-Question - Woke Up Dreaming (581 Views) Michael D. 07/14/2005 03:54PM
Re: JB-Question - Woke Up Dreaming (695 Views) 07/14/2005 04:34PM
Re: JB-Question - Woke Up Dreaming (592 Views) Michael D. 07/14/2005 04:57PM
Re: JB-Question - Woke Up Dreaming (627 Views) 07/14/2005 05:10PM
Re: JB-Question - Woke Up Dreaming (576 Views) jimbo66 07/14/2005 06:41PM
Re: JB-Question - Woke Up Dreaming (603 Views) davidrex 07/14/2005 09:40PM
Re: JB-Question - Woke Up Dreaming (519 Views) Michael D. 07/14/2005 10:07PM
Re: JB-Question - Woke Up Dreaming (645 Views) TGJB 07/15/2005 02:09PM
Re: JB-Question - Woke Up Dreaming (477 Views) Michael D. 07/15/2005 06:44PM
Re: JB-Question - Woke Up Dreaming (445 Views) jimbo66 07/15/2005 07:54PM
Re: JB-Question - Woke Up Dreaming (580 Views) Michael D. 07/15/2005 10:28PM
Re: JB-Question - Woke Up Dreaming (561 Views) TGJB 07/16/2005 02:11PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (512 Views) HP 07/12/2005 12:25PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (526 Views) Silver Charm 07/12/2005 01:42PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (488 Views) HP 07/12/2005 01:57PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (572 Views) Silver Charm 07/12/2005 02:21PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (564 Views) HP 07/12/2005 02:37PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (557 Views) Silver Charm 07/12/2005 03:00PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (454 Views) HP 07/12/2005 03:09PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (565 Views) Silver Charm 07/12/2005 03:55PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (565 Views) HP 07/12/2005 04:12PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (658 Views) TGJB 07/12/2005 04:42PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (491 Views) 07/12/2005 05:24PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (564 Views) 07/12/2005 03:38PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (587 Views) bdhsheets 07/12/2005 10:54PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (494 Views) 07/13/2005 11:34AM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (533 Views) 07/13/2005 12:57PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (545 Views) JimP 07/13/2005 02:23PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (505 Views) 07/13/2005 04:34PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (473 Views) HP 07/13/2005 05:09PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (444 Views) JimP 07/13/2005 05:30PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (718 Views) 07/14/2005 10:37AM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (516 Views) Saddlecloth 07/12/2005 03:45PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (484 Views) HP 07/12/2005 04:06PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (602 Views) Saddlecloth 07/12/2005 04:43PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (430 Views) HP 07/12/2005 05:03PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (534 Views) jimbo66 07/12/2005 05:17PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (559 Views) 07/12/2005 05:34PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (493 Views) Saddlecloth 07/12/2005 05:48PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (435 Views) Saddlecloth 07/12/2005 05:30PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (624 Views) jimbo66 07/12/2005 05:41PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (824 Views) 07/12/2005 06:03PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (582 Views) Michael D. 07/12/2005 06:18PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (490 Views) HP 07/13/2005 09:08AM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (621 Views) 07/13/2005 11:52AM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (637 Views) HP 07/13/2005 12:19PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (502 Views) 07/13/2005 01:07PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (566 Views) HP 07/13/2005 01:25PM
Calling the board police......... (564 Views) jimbo66 07/13/2005 01:54PM
Re: Calling the board police......... (643 Views) TGJB 07/13/2005 02:11PM
Re: Calling the board police......... (653 Views) marcus 07/16/2005 06:46PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (508 Views) 07/12/2005 05:03PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (478 Views) HP 07/12/2005 05:09PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (575 Views) jimbo66 07/12/2005 05:18PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (450 Views) Michael D. 07/12/2005 05:30PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (606 Views) 07/12/2005 04:41PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (547 Views) 07/12/2005 02:14PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (495 Views) Saddlecloth 07/12/2005 03:41PM
Re: Housebuster in BC (625 Views) magicnight 07/12/2005 01:07PM
You must be thinking of Groovy (516 Views) Silver Charm 07/12/2005 01:36PM
Re: You must be thinking of Groovy (547 Views) jbelfior 07/12/2005 02:28PM
Re: Housebuster in BC (537 Views) xichibanx 07/12/2005 02:30PM
Re: Housebuster in BC (626 Views) Chuckles_the_Clown2 07/12/2005 08:55PM
Re: Housebuster in BC (526 Views) Silver Charm 07/12/2005 10:18PM
Re: Housebuster in BC (454 Views) P-Dub 07/12/2005 11:11PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (699 Views) Saddlecloth 07/11/2005 03:15PM
Re: Speed is Speed, or is it? (494 Views) Saddlecloth 07/13/2005 02:40PM


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
This forum powered by Phorum.

Thoro-Graph 180 Varick Street New York, NY 10014 ---- Click here for the Ask The Experts Archives.